Keep, get rid, undecided

Soup Ladle

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,648
Likes
840
Supports
Hartlepool
Thread starter #1
Scott Loach _ KEEP
Ryan Catterick - UNDECIDED

Carl Magnay - GET RID (thanks but time to move on)
Peter Kioso - KEEP
Mark Kitching - UNDECIDED (could keep as backup but not good enough to be a regular)
Fraser Kerr - KEEP (just signed him anyway)
Kenton Richardson - GET RID (out of his depth at this level)
Myles Anderson - UNDECIDED (National League player - but need better if we want to go up any time soon.)
Aaron Cunningham - KEEP
David Edgar - GET RID (no better than what we already have)

Liam Noble - KEEP
Ryan Donaldson - KEEP
Lewis Hawkins - GET RID (useless)
Josh Hawkes - KEEP (but we won't)
Gavan Holohan - UNDECIDED
Adam Bale - KEEP (just signed)
Luke Williams - UNDECIDED (signed but hasn't kicked a ball all season. If he we get him fit he's far too good for this level but too much of an IF)
Connor Newton - GET RID (useless)
Paddy McAnonymous - GET RID
Luke Molyneux - KEEP (but I don't rate our chances)
Nicky Featherstone - GET RID

Jake Cassidy - GET RID (enjoy the National South)
Niko Muir - UNDECIDED (but think he'll move on, not fussed either way really)
Nicke Kabamba - KEEP
Luke James - KEEP
 

Chief Rocka

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,526
Likes
467
Location
Hartlepool
Supports
Hartlepool
#2
You've got that spot on for me Soup, although I don't think Kabamba will be here next season, probably wants something down South.
 

Monkey Tennis

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,025
Likes
849
Location
Barra
Supports
Bluebirds
#3
Scott Loach _ KEEP

Ryan Catterick - UNDECIDED

Carl Magnay - GET RID (thanks but time to move on)
Peter Kioso - KEEP
Mark Kitching - UNDECIDED (could keep as backup but not good enough to be a regular)
Fraser Kerr - KEEP (just signed him anyway)
Kenton Richardson - GET RID (out of his depth at this level)
Myles Anderson - UNDECIDED (National League player - but need better if we want to go up any time soon.)
Aaron Cunningham - KEEP
David Edgar - GET RID (no better than what we already have)

Liam Noble - KEEP
Ryan Donaldson - KEEP
Lewis Hawkins - GET RID (useless)
Josh Hawkes - KEEP (but we won't)
Gavan Holohan - UNDECIDED
Adam Bale - KEEP (just signed)
Luke Williams - UNDECIDED (signed but hasn't kicked a ball all season. If he we get him fit he's far too good for this level but too much of an IF)
Connor Newton - GET RID (useless)
Paddy McAnonymous - GET RID
Luke Molyneux - KEEP (but I don't rate our chances)
Nicky Featherstone - GET RID

Jake Cassidy - GET RID (enjoy the National South)
Niko Muir - UNDECIDED (but think he'll move on, not fussed either way really)
Nicke Kabamba - KEEP
Luke James - KEEP
I thought Luke James has been shite for you this season? Or has he come good since Christmas. Would love him back here.
 

Soup Ladle

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,648
Likes
840
Supports
Hartlepool
Thread starter #4
He's been a lot better since Xmas. He's the reason we've had 12,000 penalties this season. Work rate and pace means he's a constant danger but just doesn't score much.
 

BeeSting

Active Member
Messages
139
Likes
29
Supports
Barnet
#7
Mark Cousins - Get Rid
Rihards Matrevics - Get Rid

Cheye Alexander - Get Rid
Elliott Johnson - Keep (Just)
Callum Reynolds - Undecided
Ricardo Santos - Keep
Craig Robson - Get Rid
Harry Taylor - Keep (Squad Player)
David Tutonda - Keep (Will leave as Currie doesn't't like him)
Dan Sweeney (Keep) - I would sell for the right price
Darnell Smith - Get Rid
Dwight Pascal - Get Rid
Joe Payne - Get Rid
Loic Hernandez - Get Rid

Charlee Adams - Get Rid
Dan Sparkes - Get Rid
Jack Taylor - (Keep)
Simeon Akinola - Keep (Same as Tutonda)
Nana Kyei - Get Rid
Andre Boucaud - Get Rid
Wes Fonguck - Keep
Fumnaya Shomotun - Get Rid
Mauro Vilhete - Keep
Medy Elito - Get Rid
Ephron Mason-Clark - Keep at all costs

Dave Tarpey - Get Rid
Byron Harrison - Get Rid!!!!
Shaq Coulthirst - Sell
Josh Walker - Keep
Jack Barham - Get Rid
Malakai Mars - Get Rid
Mo Bettamer - Get Rid
 

#Beebot

Active Member
Messages
624
Likes
121
Location
Berkshire
Supports
Barnet, Maidenhead
#12
Mark Cousins - Get Rid
Rihards Matrevics - Get Rid

Cheye Alexander - Get Rid
Elliott Johnson - Keep (Just)
Callum Reynolds - Undecided
Ricardo Santos - Keep
Craig Robson - Get Rid
Harry Taylor - Keep (Squad Player)
David Tutonda - Keep (Will leave as Currie doesn't't like him)
Dan Sweeney (Keep) - I would sell for the right price
Darnell Smith - Get Rid
Dwight Pascal - Get Rid
Joe Payne - Get Rid
Loic Hernandez - Get Rid

Charlee Adams - Get Rid
Dan Sparkes - Get Rid
Jack Taylor - (Keep)
Simeon Akinola - Keep (Same as Tutonda)
Nana Kyei - Get Rid
Andre Boucaud - Get Rid
Wes Fonguck - Keep
Fumnaya Shomotun - Get Rid
Mauro Vilhete - Keep
Medy Elito - Get Rid
Ephron Mason-Clark - Keep at all costs

Dave Tarpey - Get Rid
Byron Harrison - Get Rid!!!!
Shaq Coulthirst - Sell
Josh Walker - Keep
Jack Barham - Get Rid
Malakai Mars - Get Rid
Mo Bettamer - Get Rid
I'd keep Barham, Boucaud and Elito, ditch Reynolds (worst captain since Jon Fortune) and I'd like to give Matrevics a chance, but otherwise I agree with this. Looks like Akinola and Tutonda are off though sadly.

The squad is enormous and needs a massive cull.
 

Fyldefan

Active Member
Messages
643
Likes
95
Location
Fylde
Supports
Afc fylde
#13
Lynch - Keep
Burke - Keep
Byrne - Keep
ZFA - Keep
Birch - Get rid
Brewitt- Get rid

Philliskirk- Get rid
Bond - Get rid
Croasdale - Keep
Montrose - Keep
Bradley - Keep
Haughton- Keep
Hardy - Get rid
Taz - Keep

Rowe - Keep

Loanees not included
 

#Beebot

Active Member
Messages
624
Likes
121
Location
Berkshire
Supports
Barnet, Maidenhead
#14
Maidenhead:

Carl Pentney - Get rid (would be surprised if there is a worse starting keeper at this level, long time coming)
Nick Hamann - Undecided (long term backup GK who never plays)

Remy Clerima - Keep
Seth Twumasi - Keep
Ryheem Sheckleford - Undecided (dual reg defender who we see little of)
Alan Massey - Undecided (very good at his best but showing signs of being past it)
Rene Steer - Keep
Ricky Gabriel - Keep
Ayo Obileye - Get rid (big clumsy CB/DM)

James Comley - Keep
Harold Odametey - Undecided (fun to watch, but has no footballing brain and doesn't seem to be getting better)
Ryan Upward - Keep
Max Worsfold - Get rid (fine technically but too lightweight)
Herson Alves - Get rid (lazy, ineffective winger, surprised Brentford had him on pro terms)
Nana Owusu - Undecided (can frighten defences but too much rubbish that goes with it)
Sean McCormack - Get rid (youngster who keeps getting loaned out to step 4)
Ravi Shamsi - Undecided (looks good when I've seen him but keeps getting loaned out)
Bradley Keetch - Keep (youngster who needs time)

Adrian Clifton - Keep (has improved so much)
Josh Kelly - Keep (but may be sold, probably the only player in our squad who will attract EFL attention)
Ryan Bird - Get rid (massive flop, highly paid and barely Isthmian standard)
James Akintunde - Get rid (works hard but limited and can't finish)

Loanees:

Mike Fondop - Undecided (started slow, has looked better recently)
Sam Nombe - Keep if we can but has another year on his contract at MK Dons who might want to give him a shot.
 

Leewilson

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
3,821
Likes
1,668
Supports
Dagenham and Redbridge
#15
Elliott Justham - Keep
Lewis Moore - Keep

Kenny Clark - Keep
Alex Davey - Get Rid
Liam Gordan - Keep
Gavin Hoyte - Undecided
Ben Nunn - Undecided
Luke Pennell - Get Rid
Nathan Smith - Keep

Liam Bellamy - Get Rid
James Blanchfield - Get Rid
Ollie Harfield - Keep
Alex McQueen - Undecided
Jack Munns - Keep
Harry Phipps - Keep
Lamar Reynolds - GET RID!!!!!
Matt Robinson - Keep

Tomi Adeloye - Keep
Chike Kandi - Undecided
Conor WIlkinson - KEEP!!!
Angelo Balanta - KEEP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Loanees:
Ben Goodliffe - Keep (but will probably stay at Wolves)
Manny Onariase - Keep (but will probably play higher)
Will Wright - Get Rid (not quite good enough for me)
Doug Loft - Get Rid (Past it)
 

B2TF

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,764
Likes
559
Location
The Moral High Ground
Supports
THE MIGHTY SHAYMEN
#16
Scott Loach _ KEEP
Ryan Catterick - UNDECIDED

Carl Magnay - GET RID (thanks but time to move on)
Peter Kioso - KEEP
Mark Kitching - UNDECIDED (could keep as backup but not good enough to be a regular)
Fraser Kerr - KEEP (just signed him anyway)
Kenton Richardson - GET RID (out of his depth at this level)
Myles Anderson - UNDECIDED (National League player - but need better if we want to go up any time soon.)
Aaron Cunningham - KEEP
David Edgar - GET RID (no better than what we already have)

Liam Noble - KEEP
Ryan Donaldson - KEEP
Lewis Hawkins - GET RID (useless)
Josh Hawkes - KEEP (but we won't)
Gavan Holohan - UNDECIDED
Adam Bale - KEEP (just signed)
Luke Williams - UNDECIDED (signed but hasn't kicked a ball all season. If he we get him fit he's far too good for this level but too much of an IF)
Connor Newton - GET RID (useless)
Paddy McAnonymous - GET RID
Luke Molyneux - KEEP (but I don't rate our chances)
Nicky Featherstone - GET RID

Jake Cassidy - GET RID (enjoy the National South)
Niko Muir - UNDECIDED (but think he'll move on, not fussed either way really)
Nicke Kabamba - KEEP
Luke James - KEEP
Get shut of them all, they're as crap as our lot!:fl:
 

jacobncfc

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,341
Likes
412
Supports
notts county
#18
Lynch - Keep
Burke - Keep
Byrne - Keep
ZFA - Keep
Birch - Get rid
Brewitt- Get rid

Philliskirk- Get rid
Bond - Get rid
Croasdale - Keep
Montrose - Keep
Bradley - Keep
Haughton- Keep
Hardy - Get rid
Taz - Keep

Rowe - Keep

Loanees not included
How's Tom Crawford doing?

Assuming we're coming down, I'd be keen to see our entire team and management interred at Guantanamo Bay, but maybe he can be an exception.
 

Fyldefan

Active Member
Messages
643
Likes
95
Location
Fylde
Supports
Afc fylde
#19
How's Tom Crawford doing?

Assuming we're coming down, I'd be keen to see our entire team and management interred at Guantanamo Bay, but maybe he can be an exception.
He looked a class above everybody else on the pitch today. Superb with the ball. Maybe lacks a bit off it
 
Messages
31
Likes
3
Location
Essex
Supports
Dagenham And Redbridge
#20
Elliott Justham - Keep | Player of the season for us.
Lewis Moore - Keep |Given everything you’d want from a second choice keeper performance and attitude wise.

Kenny Clark - Keep |
Alex Davey - Keep | Solid enough for a backup option
Liam Gordan - Keep |Will go far
Gavin Hoyte - Get Rid
Ben Nunn - Get Rid | Absolutely wonderful professional and ambassador to the club but just not consist enough for a captain
Luke Pennell - Get Rid | Minor winds are enough to put him out for 3 months currently
Nathan Smith - Get Rid | Good player but I can’t see another season in him

Liam Bellamy - Get Rid
James Blanchfield - Get Rid
Ollie Harfield - Get Rid
Alex McQueen - Keep
Jack Munns - Get Rid | Good technically but gets too easily marshalled out of games, over hyped imo
Harry Phipps - Keep
Lamar Reynolds - Get Rid
Matt Robinson - Keep | Bench option for me

Tomi Adeloye - Keep
Chike Kandi - Keep
Conor Wilkinson - Keep
Angelo Balanta - Keep

Loanees:
Ben Goodliffe - Keep
Manny Onariase - Keep | Way too good at this level, one of the most impressive players I’ve seen this year.
Will Wright - Get Rid
Doug Loft - Get Rid | yet another who technically is great but floats through some games.
 

Harrier94

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,969
Likes
814
Location
Kidderminster
Supports
Kidderminster Harriers
#22
Lynch - Keep
Burke - Keep
Byrne - Keep
ZFA - Keep
Birch - Get rid
Brewitt- Get rid

Philliskirk- Get rid
Bond - Get rid
Croasdale - Keep
Montrose - Keep
Bradley - Keep
Haughton- Keep
Hardy - Get rid
Taz - Keep

Rowe - Keep

Loanees not included
No Tunnicliffe? How are the ex Harriers players doing?
 

Fyldefan

Active Member
Messages
643
Likes
95
Location
Fylde
Supports
Afc fylde
#24
No Tunnicliffe? How are the ex Harriers players doing?
Shit yeah tunny, I'd keep him but personally I'd try and bring another centre back in. He has serious lapses in concentration. Croasdale has done alright, he gets absolutely slated where I sit because 9 times out of 10 he goes sideways or backwards but hes done alright. He wont be in that position when Montrose is back. ZFA is always pretty consistent. If he was a bit better with his feet he wouldn't be in this league. Oh and Bradley, started off superbly. Been a bit below par last few games.
 

chief

Well-Known Member
Messages
802
Likes
280
Location
Wrexham
Supports
Wrexham
#26
Rob Lainton - Keep
Christian Dibble - Keep

Kevin Roberts - Get rid
James Jennings - Keep
Shaun Pearson - Signed up, would obviously keep
Manny Smith - Keep if he can recover from his injury, rumour is he's signed up already
Doug Tharme - Undecided, haven't seen enough of him to register an opinion. Possibly let him go out on loan
Jake Lawlor - Signed up, would keep
Kieran Kennedy - Undecided

Paul Rutherford - Keep if we're still at this level, get rid if we go up
Mark Carrington - Same as above
Luke Young - Signed up, keep
Akil Wright - Signed up, keep
Leo Smith - Get rid
Nicky Deverdics - Get rid
Luke Summerfield - Keep
Bobby Grant - Get rid
Kemy Agustien - Undecided, no idea what's going on with him

Chris Holroyd - Get rid
Mike Fondop-Talom - Signed up, sell
Stuart Beavon - Keep. Not our player but I doubt he'll be in Coventry's plans next season
Jason Oswell - Signed up, but jury's still out on him
 

fifaking

Active Member
Messages
439
Likes
88
Supports
Wrexham
#28
Rob Lainton - Keep
Christian Dibble - Keep

Kevin Roberts - Get rid
James Jennings - Keep
Shaun Pearson - Signed up, would obviously keep
Manny Smith - Keep if he can recover from his injury, rumour is he's signed up already
Doug Tharme - Undecided, haven't seen enough of him to register an opinion. Possibly let him go out on loan
Jake Lawlor - Signed up, would keep
Kieran Kennedy - Undecided

Paul Rutherford - Keep if we're still at this level, get rid if we go up
Mark Carrington - Same as above
Luke Young - Signed up, keep
Akil Wright - Signed up, keep
Leo Smith - Get rid
Nicky Deverdics - Get rid
Luke Summerfield - Keep
Bobby Grant - Get rid
Kemy Agustien - Undecided, no idea what's going on with him

Chris Holroyd - Get rid
Mike Fondop-Talom - Signed up, sell
Stuart Beavon - Keep. Not our player but I doubt he'll be in Coventry's plans next season
Jason Oswell - Signed up, but jury's still out on him
I'd bin off Akil Wright.. too many games completely pass him by. I also like Kennedy and would keep him but we don't need 4 CBs when so many other positions need sorting. The rest I completely agree with
 

chief

Well-Known Member
Messages
802
Likes
280
Location
Wrexham
Supports
Wrexham
#29
I'd bin off Akil Wright.. too many games completely pass him by. I also like Kennedy and would keep him but we don't need 4 CBs when so many other positions need sorting. The rest I completely agree with
Yeah that's why I'm undecided on him. It most likely depends on Manny regaining fitness. If he can't then we'd may as well sign up Kennedy, but I suspect he'll be taking too much of a wage for a 4th choice CB.
 

Monkey Tennis

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,025
Likes
849
Location
Barra
Supports
Bluebirds
#30
Goalk
Joel Dixon - signed up already, Keep
Jonny Saltmer - never played, undecided

Defenders
Josh Granite - keep
Dan Jones - keep (Though will probably move up to L2)
Jack Barthram - keep
Connor Brown - get rid
Matthew Elsdon - signed up, but injury prone
Brian Wilson - get rid
Lee Molyneux - get rid
Christian Sloan - no idea, undecided
Sam Hird - signed up, keep

Midfielders
Josh Kay - signed up, keep
John Rooney - get rid
Jason Taylor - keep
Steve Jennings - get rid
Lewis Hardcastle - signed up, keep

Strikers
Nathan Waterston - get rid
Jack Hindle - get rid
Jacob Blyth - get rid
Rhys Turner - injury prone, undecided
Jamie Philpot - undecided
Nathan Reid - get rid

We have been pretty pro-active in signing up some players already, and if we could keep our loanees Kyle Jamieson and Rhys Norrington-Davies, I'd be delighted. But a lot of dead wood to get rid of, as well as current first choice players who are popular but not quite up to standard, in my opinion.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
14,366
Messages
859,637
Members
4,754
Latest member
Hammersfan